Other Posts

What Makes a Great Merch Design?

Merch is more than just a shirt, hoodie, or tote — it’s a walking billboard, a conversation starter, and sometimes even a collectible. The best designs stick in people’s minds long after they’ve worn (or even washed) them. But what actually makes a piece of merch great instead of just… another free shirt at the bottom of the drawer?

At Hardboiled Inc., we’ve printed thousands of pieces for Toronto businesses, artists, events, and brands. We’ve seen what gets people excited — and what gets ignored. Here’s what we’ve learned.

1. Keep It Simple, But Not Boring

The most wearable merch designs are easy to read and quick to “get” at a glance. That doesn’t mean you have to play it safe. Bold typography, clean graphics, and high-contrast colour choices make a piece pop without overwhelming the eye. If someone can’t read or understand your design in under three seconds, it’s probably too busy.

best for screen printed t-shirts

Example: Think about the Nike “Swoosh” or Toronto’s iconic six typography. Minimal shapes, but instantly recognizable.

Why simple works:

  • People process your design at a glance, even from a distance.
  • Simple designs tend to work across more garment colours and print methods.
  • They’re easier to scale or adapt for hats, bags, and hoodies.

 

Pro tip: If your design looks good as a one-inch thumbnail, it’ll work on a full-sized shirt.

Match the Design to the Printing Method

Each printing method has its strengths. Screen printing makes bold, vibrant designs last for years. DTG and DTF shine for full-colour photographic artwork. Embroidery gives a premium, textured look that’s perfect for hats and jackets. If you design with the print method in mind, you’ll avoid compromises later.

DTG print matching design to print method

Print Method Strengths:

Screen printing: Best for bold, vibrant designs with limited colours (e.g., 1–4 colours). Inks last for years without fading.
DTG (Direct to Garment): Perfect for full-colour, photo-quality images or complex gradients.
DTF (Direct to Film): Similar to DTG, but more durable on certain fabrics and allows for easy heat transfers.
Embroidery: Adds texture, depth, and a premium feel. Ideal for logos, caps, and outerwear.

Example: If you’re printing a full-colour mural design, DTG or DTF is your go-to. But for a bold streetwear logo? Screen print it on a heavyweight hoodie for maximum impact.

Choose Colours That Work on Fabric

Ink colours don’t always look the same on fabric as they do on your laptop screen. Especially if you’re going from RGB to real ink or thread. Light colours stand out best on dark fabrics, while dark colours pop on lighter garments. Want something subtle? Tone-on-tone prints or embroidery can look sleek and high-end. A good printer (hi 👋) will guide you on what works best for your chosen garment colour.

tone on tone embroidery for found coffee

Best practices when choosing imprint colours

  • Use high-contrast colours for readability (white ink on black shirts = classic).
  • On darker fabrics, add an underbase layer so colours stay vibrant.
  • For embroidery, consider thread sheen and how light hits it.
  • Stay away from designing with web only colours

 

Example: A deep red logo on a black hoodie might disappear in low light. Swap that red for bright yellow or neon orange and suddenly it’s streetwear gold.

Design for Your Audience, Not Just Yourself

The best merch resonates with the people wearing it. A punk band’s fans might want loud graphics and heavy ink coverage. A coffee shop might go for a minimalist, earthy vibe. Think about your audience’s style, not just your own preferences. That’s how you create merch people actually want to wear outside the house.

embroidered polo for custom corporate wear

Considerations when making design decisions:

  • Who’s wearing this?
  • Will they rock it at work, at the gym, or at a concert?
  • Do they want bold graphics or something minimal?

 

Examples:

  • Band merch: Bigger, bolder, sometimes chaotic prints that match the music’s energy.
  • Coffee shop merch: Minimalist, earthy tones, small logo placements.
  • Corporate merch: Clean, polished, often with subtle branding.

Make It Timeless (or Intentionally Limited)

Great merch has staying power or it makes an impact by being here and gone.

Timeless pieces:

  • Logo tees and embroidered caps.
  • Neutral colours that match anything.
  • Simple designs that stay relevant.

 

Limited runs:

  • Event-specific graphics.
  • Collabs with artists or brands.
  • Seasonal colourways.

 

Example: Toronto streetwear brands often drop small runs that sell out fast — creating hype and scarcity.

Let’s Get Started

Great merch isn’t just about looking cool on screen, it’s got to translate well in real life. Whether it’s your brand’s history, your band’s identity, or your event’s energy, a great design with the right print method will have your merch flying off the shelves or leaving a lasting impact.

And when you’re ready to bring that design to life? We’ve got the printing methods, the garment selection, and the experience to make it happen.

Visit us in downtown Toronto or browse our online catalogue to get started on your next merch drop.

Search
Your cart is empty
Search

Select Currency

{CC} - {CN}
Cancel